%PDF-1.3
%%�����
%%Page: 1 1            
4 0 obj
<<
/Length 5 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 664.5 Tm
/F1 13 Tf 100 Tz
88.1395 -8.4 Td
1.3 Tw
0 Tc
(FOR PUBLICATION) Tj
/F1 15 Tf 100 Tz
-78.2395 -24 Td
1.5 Tw
(UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS) Tj
43.47 -15.7 Td
(FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-53.37 -18 Td
1.2 Tw
() Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
0 0 Td
183.8 0 Td
/F3 20 Tf 100 Tz
-2.18 -17.6 Td
2 Tw
(�) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-181.62 -2.8 Td
1.2 Tw
(J) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(OHN) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( D) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(, ) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(AND) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( J) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(ANE) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( D) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(,) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
76.332 -13.2 Td
(Plaintiffs-Appellees,) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
138.738 -6.6 Td
(No. 01-35419) Tj
-132.57 -11.4 Td
(v.) Tj
144.234 -6.6 Td
(D.C. No.) Tj
-226.734 -11.4 Td
(G) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(EORGE) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( J. T) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(, Individually and) Tj
202.668 -1.8 Td
(CV-99-01597-RSL) Tj
/F3 20 Tf 100 Tz
-21.048 -7.9 Td
2 Tw
(�) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-181.62 -3.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(as Director of Central Intelligence) Tj
201.81 -1.8 Td
(Western District of) Tj
-201.81 -11.4 Td
(and Director of the Central) Tj
200.07 -1.8 Td
(Washington, Seattle) Tj
-200.07 -11.4 Td
(Intelligence Agency; U) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(NITED) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
228.666 -6.6 Td
1.2 Tw
(ORDER) Tj
-228.666 -6.6 Td
(S) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(TATES) Tj
2.12 Tw
( ) Tj
.79 Tw
(OF) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( A) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(MERICA) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(,) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
61.008 -13.2 Td
(Defendants-Appellants.) Tj
/F3 20 Tf 100 Tz
120.612 -8.8 Td
1.6 Ts
2 Tw
(�) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-85.416 -25.8 Td
1.2 Tw
(Filed January 7, 2004) Tj
-76.488 -25.8 Td
(Before: William) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(C.) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Canby,) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Jr., Marsha) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(S.) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Berzon and) Tj
42.588 -12.9 Td
(Richard) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(C.) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Tallman, Circuit Judges.) Tj
72.036 -25.8 Td
(Order;) Tj
-51.3 -12.9 Td
(Dissent by Judge Kleinfeld) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
45.294 -43.5 Td
(ORDER) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-116.334 -25.9 Td
.2 Tw
(The majority of the panel has voted to deny appellee's peti-) Tj
-12 -13 Td
1.85 Tw
(tion for rehearing and petition for rehearing en banc. Judge) Tj
0 -13 Td
2.41 Tw
(Canby votes to deny the petition for rehearing and recom-) Tj
0 -13 Td
.24 Tw
(mends denial of the petition for rehearing en banc. Judge Ber-) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.53 Tw
(zon votes to deny the petition for rehearing and the petition) Tj
0 -13 Td
.97 Tw
(for rehearing en banc. Judge Tallman votes to grant the peti-) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.2 Tw
(tion for rehearing and the petition for rehearing en banc. ) Tj
12 -25.9 Td
.2 Tw
(The full court has been advised of the petition for rehearing) Tj
-12 -13 Td
2.3 Tw
(en banc. An active judge requested a vote on whether this) Tj
0 -13 Td
.57 Tw
(matter should be reheard before an en banc panel. The matter) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 664.5 cm
0 G
.9 w 0 -65.65 m 183.8 -65.65 l s
1.2 w 186.6 -129.8 m 186.6 -73.5 l s
1.2 w 186.6 -203.1 m 186.6 -146.8 l s
.9 w 0 -210.05 m 183.3 -210.05 l s
.5 w 0 -338.05 m 300 -338.05 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
297.75 -664.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(171) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
3751
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F3 8 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 4 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 2 2            
12 0 obj
<<
/Length 13 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
1.94 Tw
0 Tc
(failed to receive a majority of the votes of the non-recused) Tj
0 -13.6 Td
2.81 Tw
(active judges in favor of en banc reconsideration. Fed. R.) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(App. P. 35\(b\). ) Tj
12 -26.8 Td
.77 Tw
(The petition for rehearing and the petition for rehearing en) Tj
-12 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(banc are DENIED. ) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -52.4 Td
5.21 Tw
(KLEINFELD, Circuit Judge, with whom Circuit Judges) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
6.25 Tw
(KOZINSKI, O'SCANNLAIN, TALLMAN, BYBEE and) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
3.32 Tw
(CALLAHAN join, dissenting from denial of rehearing en) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(banc: ) Tj
12 -26.8 Td
1.42 Tw
(I respectfully dissent from the order denying rehearing en) Tj
-12 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(banc. ) Tj
12 -26.8 Td
2.22 Tw
(�Doe) Tj
(� is a pseudonym, because Mr. and Mrs. Doe were) Tj
-12 -13.5 Td
.17 Tw
(apparently spies for the United States in the Soviet empire. Of) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.42 Tw
(course, all we know is what the Does now allege. The facts) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
3.71 Tw
(are unconfirmed. The case comes up on an interlocutory) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.4 Tw
(appeal of a district court order denying the CIA's motion to) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(dismiss. ) Tj
12 -26.7 Td
2.6 Tw
(Mr. Doe was a diplomat for one of the ) Tj
(�republics.) Tj
(� He) Tj
-12 -13.5 Td
.63 Tw
(sought to defect to the United States. He and Mrs. Doe alleg-) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.83 Tw
(edly made a deal with the CIA. Mr. Doe would stay in his) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.19 Tw
(position for a while and spy for us, and the CIA would then) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
.3 Tw
(arrange the Does' defection and resettlement, and ensure their) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.3 Tw
(personal and financial security for the rest of their lives. All) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
3.92 Tw
(went fine for some time, with false identities and back-) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
.8 Tw
(grounds. But then the American bank Mr. Doe worked for in) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.37 Tw
(Seattle merged with another, and Mr. Doe was laid off. The) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
.66 Tw
(CIA left him without assistance, despite an earlier promise to) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
2.96 Tw
(resume financial aid if he became unemployed. The Does) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
.7 Tw
(sued for an order directing the CIA to provide them with due) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(process and to pay them the money they were promised. ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -101.15 m 300 -101.15 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(172) Tj
119.5303 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
2820
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 12 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 3 3            
15 0 obj
<<
/Length 16 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -8.4 Td
2.6 Tw
0 Tc
(The issue is whether they can get into a federal district) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
2.14 Tw
(court with their claims. The long-established answer, under) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.22 Tw
(the Supreme Court's opinion in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten v. United States) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(,) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(1) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( has) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.27 Tw
(been that they cannot. Under ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, those who spy for us) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.81 Tw
(cannot bring lawsuits to enforce our intelligence agencies') Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.37 Tw
(promises, because that would require exposure of matters that) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.77 Tw
(must be kept secret in the interest of effective foreign policy.) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.71 Tw
(The panel opinion effectively overrules ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(. It holds that) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.2 Td
.77 Tw
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
('s rationale is out of date and that subsequent Supreme) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.62 Tw
(Court decisions undermine it. Under ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Agostini v. Felton) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(,) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(2) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( we) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.73 Tw
(cannot do that. Also, in reaching its conclusion, the panel) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.76 Tw
(decision puts us is in conflict with the Federal Circuit, which) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(complied with ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Guong v. United States) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(3) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
12 -26.1 Td
1.03 Tw
(Aside from the intelligence aspect of this case, the Tucker) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
.7 Tw
(Act requires those who sue the government for broken prom-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.02 Tw
(ises to do so in the Court of Federal Claims, not in a district) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.43 Tw
(court.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(4) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( By allowing the Does' suit to go forward despite the) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.26 Tw
(Tucker Act, the panel opinion departs from our precedent in) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(an area where there already existed an intercircuit conflict. ) Tj
0 -26.1 Td
(I.) Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Spies) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( ) Tj
12 -26.1 Td
1.46 Tw
(The case at bar is factually indistinguishable from ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(.) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
2.22 Tw
(In 1861, Abraham Lincoln, on behalf of the United States,) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.53 Tw
(personally hired William A. Lloyd to spy behind Confederate) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.91 Tw
(lines for the duration of the war, agreeing to pay him $200 a) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
0 Tw
(month for his services.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(5) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Lloyd subsequently died intestate, and) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.25 Tw
(his administrator, Totten, sued the government in the Court of) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -26 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(1) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Totten v. United States) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 92 U.S. 105 \(1875\). ) Tj
0 -14 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(2) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Agostini v. Felton) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 521 U.S. 203, 237 \(1997\). ) Tj
0 -14 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(3) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Guong v. United States) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 860 F.2d 1063 \(Fed. Cir. 1988\). ) Tj
0 -14 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(4) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(See ) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(28 U.S.C. �) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1 Tw
(1491\(a\). ) Tj
0 -14 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.1 Tw
(5) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(This is in the same order of magnitude as the Does' agreement � $200) Tj
-10 -11.2 Td
1.1 Tw
(in 1861 being the equivalent in purchasing power to about $4,000 today) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
1.33 Tw
(\(to the extent that economists' inflation factors can indicate equivalence) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
1 Tw
(despite technological change\). ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -388.15 m 300 -388.15 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
439.5 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(173) Tj
-163.9697 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
4562
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 15 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 4 4            
19 0 obj
<<
/Length 20 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.37 Tw
0 Tc
(Claims for Lloyd's unpaid compensation. The Supreme Court) Tj
0 -13 Td
.85 Tw
(held, in the broadest terms, that contracts for clandestine ser-) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.57 Tw
(vice to the government can never be sued upon. It said that) Tj
0 -13 Td
.67 Tw
(such agreements necessarily contain the term that the parties') Tj
0 -13 Td
1.07 Tw
(�lips . .) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.07 Tw
(. were to be for ever sealed,) Tj
(� a term that is ) Tj
(�implied) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.23 Tw
(in all secret employments of the government in time of war,) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.26 Tw
(or upon matters affecting our foreign relations.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(6) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Here is the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(heart of the Court's holding: ) Tj
22 -25.9 Td
.5 Tw
(Our objection is not to the contract, but to the action) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.06 Tw
(upon it in the Court of Claims. The service stipulated) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.75 Tw
(by the contract was a secret service; the information) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.95 Tw
(sought was to be obtained clandestinely, and was to) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.55 Tw
(be communicated privately; the employment and the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.28 Tw
(service were to be equally concealed. Both employer) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.28 Tw
(and agent must have understood that the lips of the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.07 Tw
(other were to be for ever sealed respecting the rela-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.66 Tw
(tion of either to the matter. This condition of the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
4.14 Tw
(engagement was implied from the nature of the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.94 Tw
(employment, and is implied in all secret employ-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.51 Tw
(ments of the government in time of war, or upon) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.34 Tw
(matters affecting our foreign relations, where a dis-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.47 Tw
(closure of the service might compromise or embar-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.46 Tw
(rass our government in its public duties, or endanger) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.66 Tw
(the person or injure the character of the agent. If) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.55 Tw
(upon contracts of such a nature an action against the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.57 Tw
(government could be maintained in the Court of) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.83 Tw
(Claims, whenever an agent should deem himself) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.45 Tw
(entitled to greater or different compensation than) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.22 Tw
(that awarded to him, the whole service in any case,) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.47 Tw
(and the manner of its discharge, with the details of) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
4.5 Tw
(dealings with individuals and officers, might be) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.41 Tw
(exposed, to the serious detriment of the public. A) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.82 Tw
(secret service, with liability to publicity in this way,) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.03 Tw
(would be impossible; and, as such services are some-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.14 Tw
(times indispensable to the government, its agents in) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
-12 -25.9 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(6) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Totten) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 92 U.S. at 106. ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -477.85 m 300 -477.85 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(174) Tj
119.5303 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
3523
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 19 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 5 5            
22 0 obj
<<
/Length 23 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
22 -8.4 Td
2.04 Tw
0 Tc
(those services must look for their compensation to) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
3.43 Tw
(the contingent fund of the department employing) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
2.07 Tw
(them, and to such allowance from it as those who) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
2.38 Tw
(dispense that fund may award. The secrecy which) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
.9 Tw
(such contracts impose precludes any action for their) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
2.71 Tw
(enforcement. The publicity produced by an action) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
1.7 Tw
(would itself be a breach of a contract of that kind,) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
1.2 Tw
(and thus defeat a recovery.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(7) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
-10 -28.3 Td
1.42 Tw
(The Does' case is factually indistinguishable from ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(.) Tj
-12 -14.3 Td
.36 Tw
(Like William Lloyd, the Does were engaged to provide secret) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
.55 Tw
(services to the United States behind enemy lines. Like Lloyd,) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
.09 Tw
(they served to the great benefit of the United States in circum-) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
1.81 Tw
(stances that could have gotten them killed. And like Lloyd,) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
2.07 Tw
(they allegedly got stiffed by the government providing less) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
2.08 Tw
(compensation than required by the contracts when the time) Tj
0 -14.3 Td
1.2 Tw
(came for the United States to pay up. ) Tj
12 -28.3 Td
2.77 Tw
(The panel held, however, that ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( is no longer good) Tj
-12 -14.3 Td
2.03 Tw
(authority. As for the contractual aspects of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, the ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Doe) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -14.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(panel held that ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( was inapplicable for two reasons: ) Tj
22 -28.3 Td
1.39 Tw
(First, . . . unlike Totten, the Does do not seek only) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
0 Tw
(enforcement of a contract. Rather their principal con-) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
1.41 Tw
(cern at this point . . . is to compel fair process and) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
1 Tw
(application of substantive law to their claims within) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
.83 Tw
(the Central Intelligence Agency[) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.83 Tw
(]. . . . Second, ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Tot-) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
7.66 Tw
(ten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( assumed ) Tj
(�publicity) Tj
(� inconsistent with the) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
1.41 Tw
(implicit promise of secrecy as inherent in any judi-) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
1.85 Tw
(cial proceeding and did not consider whether there) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
2.45 Tw
(are means to conduct judicial proceedings without) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
5.17 Tw
(unacceptable attendant ) Tj
(�publicity.) Tj
(� Since ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(,) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
.11 Tw
(courts, including the Supreme Court, have developed) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
-12 -28 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(7) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Id.) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( at 106-07. ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -476.65 m 300 -476.65 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
439.5 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(175) Tj
-163.9697 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
3493
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 22 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 6 6            
25 0 obj
<<
/Length 26 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
22 -8.4 Td
1.66 Tw
0 Tc
(means of accommodating asserted national security) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(interests in judicial proceedings. . . .) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(8) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
-22 -26 Td
2.48 Tw
(The panel then reinterprets the remainder of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( as ) Tj
(�an) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.77 Tw
(early expression of the evidentiary state secrets privilege,) Tj
(�) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.5 Tw
(which only allows for dismissal ) Tj
(�) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(after ) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(complying with the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.78 Tw
(formalities and court investigation requirements that have) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(developed since ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(9) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
12 -26 Td
.66 Tw
(As Judge Tallman's dissent points out, every aspect of this) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
.81 Tw
(rationale is mistaken. The most obvious way that the opinion) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.15 Tw
(is wrong is that, no matter how much the courts have devel-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.12 Tw
(oped routines for handling assertions of official secrets, a) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.3 Tw
(lower court cannot overrule the Supreme Court. Whether sub-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
4 Tw
(sequent Supreme Court authority implicitly undermines a) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.66 Tw
(Supreme Court decision or not, lower courts must follow and) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.06 Tw
(apply a controlling Supreme Court decision. As the Court said) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
0 Tw
(in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Agostini) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, ) Tj
(�[w]e reaffirm that if a precedent of this Court has) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.5 Tw
(direct application in a case, yet appears to rest on reasons) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.57 Tw
(rejected in some other line of decisions, the Court of Appeals) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.51 Tw
(should follow the case which directly controls, leaving to this) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.12 Tw
(Court the prerogative of overruling its own decisions.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(10) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( The) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(Supreme Court can overrule ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(. We cannot. ) Tj
12 -26 Td
1.95 Tw
(Second, the gossamer distinctions the panel tries to draw) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
2.7 Tw
(between the Does' and Totten's claims for the purpose of) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.95 Tw
(defeating ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
('s language about implied secrecy terms do) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.02 Tw
(not amount to anything. Whether it is called a plea for fairer) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.2 Tw
(process or a simple contract claim for damages, the Does, like) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.52 Tw
(Totten's decedent, sue the government to obtain a remedy for) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.47 Tw
(its breach of an agreement to compensate them for intelli-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.87 Tw
(gence services. In both cases, the engagements were secret,) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.57 Tw
(obviously and necessarily so, since doubtless both engage-) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -25.8 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.7 Tw
(8) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Doe v. Tenet) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 329 F.3d 1135, 1147-48 \(9th Cir. 2003\) \(internal quota-) Tj
-10 -11.2 Td
1 Tw
(tions omitted\). ) Tj
10 -13.9 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(9) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Id.) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( at 1149, 1150 \(emphasis in original\). ) Tj
0 -14 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(10) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Agostini) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 521 U.S. at 237 \(internal quotation omitted\). ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -438.75 m 300 -438.75 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(176) Tj
119.5303 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
4135
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 25 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 7 7            
28 0 obj
<<
/Length 29 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.62 Tw
0 Tc
(ments involved the commission of serious crimes in the loca-) Tj
0 -13 Td
2.96 Tw
(tions where the intelligence agents were to perform them.) Tj
0 -13 Td
4.41 Tw
(Both also would amount to serious provocations by the) Tj
0 -13 Td
2.6 Tw
(United States in the eyes of the governing forces in those) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.2 Tw
(locations. ) Tj
12 -25.9 Td
1.44 Tw
(The panel's contention that the purposes of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( can be) Tj
-12 -13 Td
.78 Tw
(served by the CIA asserting the state-secrets privilege, which) Tj
0 -13 Td
.87 Tw
(would then permit in camera inspection of papers by the dis-) Tj
0 -13 Td
.36 Tw
(trict court and so forth, leaves out the most important purpose) Tj
0 -13 Td
3.14 Tw
(of all: to keep the whole engagement utterly and entirely) Tj
0 -13 Td
2.66 Tw
(secret. I see no reason that progress in judicial techniques) Tj
0 -13 Td
2.05 Tw
(should make any difference. Intelligence is such an ancient) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.36 Tw
(part of conflict that the Bible suggested nothing novel when) Tj
0 -13 Td
.18 Tw
(Joshua sent spies to reconnoiter Jericho.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(11) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Circumstances have) Tj
0 -13 Td
.21 Tw
(not changed materially. The very existence of the engagement) Tj
0 -13 Td
.87 Tw
(has to be secret and has to remain secret. If a lawsuit is filed) Tj
0 -13 Td
.73 Tw
(but some papers remain secret, that is not enough. An intelli-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.91 Tw
(gent observer, knowing something of the events, can figure) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.02 Tw
(out from the barest indications in a lawsuit what it is all about.) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.21 Tw
(As ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( says, ) Tj
(�such services are sometimes indispensable to) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.18 Tw
(the government,) Tj
(� and ) Tj
(�[a] secret service, with liability to pub-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.45 Tw
(licity in this way, would be impossible.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(12) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Sometimes, to) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.53 Tw
(avoid provocations to war or other diplomatic imbroglios, the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.51 Tw
(government has to avoid disclosing what it did, even long) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.06 Tw
(after it has done it. Spying is among the ) Tj
(�matters affecting our) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.37 Tw
(foreign relations, where a disclosure of the service might) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
-1.21 Tw
(compromise or embarrass our government in its public duties.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(13) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -25.9 Td
.87 Tw
(The panel's assurances that there is nothing to fear are not) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
.5 Tw
(enough in light of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( and its purposes. Requiring the CIA) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.66 Tw
(to abide by the formalities of making a privilege claim will) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.4 Tw
(involve the CIA having to deny or disclose the very existence) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.7 Tw
(of the secret relationship. Even asserting that there is a secret) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -25.6 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(11) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Joshua 2:1, et seq. ) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(12) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Totten) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 92 U.S. at 107. ) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(13) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Id.) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( at 106. ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -450.15 m 300 -450.15 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
439.5 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(177) Tj
-163.9697 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
29 0 obj
3975
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 28 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 8 8            
32 0 obj
<<
/Length 33 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.58 Tw
0 Tc
(to protect, as the state-secrets privilege used in other contexts) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
1.27 Tw
(requires, amounts to letting the cat out of the bag. It is such) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
3.67 Tw
(disclosure of the relationship's very existence that ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.4 Td
.36 Tw
(sought to avoid. And where there is no espionage relationship) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
.83 Tw
(to protect, the CIA will have to say as much. That will make) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
1.2 Tw
(all non-denials effectively confirmations. ) Tj
12 -26.5 Td
1.36 Tw
(The panel's attempt to interpret ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( so narrowly that it) Tj
-12 -13.4 Td
2.91 Tw
(does not even apply to a case materially indistinguishable) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
.84 Tw
(from it puts us in conflict with the Federal Circuit. In ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Guong) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
.26 Tw
(v. United States) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, the plaintiff tried to distinguish ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( on the) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
2.33 Tw
(ground that the CIA had hired him as a saboteur in North) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
1.07 Tw
(Vietnam, and not as a spy.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(14) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( The Federal Circuit rejected the) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
.82 Tw
(distinction and any other narrowing of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(: ) Tj
(�) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( stands) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
.2 Tw
(for the proposition that no action can be brought to enforce an) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
.83 Tw
(alleged contract with the government when, at the time of its) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
1.2 Tw
(creation, the contract was secret or covert.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(15) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -26.5 Td
1.95 Tw
(Guong) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( also rejected the plaintiff's attempt, similar to the) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
-12 -13.3 Td
1.77 Tw
(Doe) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( panel's, to assimilate ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( into cases about the state-) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
1.21 Tw
(secrets evidentiary privilege. Privilege cases, including ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Web-) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
1.3 Tw
(ster v. Doe) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(16) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( and ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(United States v. Reynolds) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(,) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(17) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( do not involve) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
1.53 Tw
(engagements of spies in foreign countries, but rather disclo-) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
.51 Tw
(sures during litigation about other kinds of secrets. As ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Guong) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.3 Td
1.7 Tw
(held, ) Tj
(�[a] close reading of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Reynolds) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( reveals that it does not) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
3.17 Tw
(limit or modify the authority of ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( or its rationale.) Tj
(�) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(18) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.3 Td
.93 Tw
(Guong) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( also makes the point that ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( is not limited to cur-) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
.51 Tw
(rently active spies. Even in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, there was no direct risk of) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
.44 Tw
(harm from ongoing conflicts, because the Civil War had been) Tj
0 -13.3 Td
.45 Tw
(over for ten years when the Court decided the case.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(19) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Thus, in) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -26.4 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(14) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Guong) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 860 F.2d at 1065. ) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(15) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Id.) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( ) Tj
0 -14.1 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(16) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Webster v. Doe) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 486 U.S. 592 \(1988\). ) Tj
0 -14.1 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(17) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(United States v. Reynolds) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 345 U.S. 1 \(1953\). ) Tj
0 -14.1 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(18) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(Guong) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 860 F.2d at 1066. ) Tj
0 -14.1 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(19) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(See ) Tj
(id.) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( at 1065. ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -406.95 m 300 -406.95 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(178) Tj
119.5303 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
33 0 obj
5000
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 32 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 9 9            
35 0 obj
<<
/Length 36 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
2.92 Tw
0 Tc
(the Federal Circuit, unlike in the Ninth Circuit after ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Doe) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(,) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( remains good law. ) Tj
0 -26.7 Td
(II.) Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Tucker Act) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( ) Tj
12 -26.7 Td
1.07 Tw
(The Tucker Act grants jurisdiction to the Court of Federal) Tj
-12 -13.5 Td
2.45 Tw
(Claims to hear contract actions against the United States.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(20) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.5 Td
1.58 Tw
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( itself was brought under a predecessor to the present) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
2.05 Tw
(Tucker Act.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(21) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( The Tucker Act's conferral of jurisdiction on) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
.88 Tw
(the Court of Federal Claims has been read to be exclusive of) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1 Tw
(district court jurisdiction when the amount at stake is greater) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.2 Tw
(than $10,000.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(22) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
12 -26.7 Td
3.08 Tw
(The panel opinion, however, reads the Tucker Act nar-) Tj
-12 -13.5 Td
1.7 Tw
(rowly, so that even though the Does' claims are in the first) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.41 Tw
(instance dependent on the contract, the Does can proceed in) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
.57 Tw
(district court. The panel so holds because the Does purport to) Tj
0 -13.5 Td
1.72 Tw
(base their claims on a denial of due process and phrase the) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
1.37 Tw
(relief they seek as declaratory and injunctive. Those distinc-) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
.63 Tw
(tions have no force, however, as we held in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Tucson Airport) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(23) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.4 Td
.83 Tw
(There is apparently a circuit conflict between ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Tucson Airport) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.4 Td
1.23 Tw
(and the District of Columbia Circuit's decision in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Transohio) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
1.45 Tw
(Savings Bank v. Director, Office of Thrift Supervision) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(24) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( But) Tj
0 -13.4 Td
.17 Tw
(this issue should not have been reached here, because the case) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -26.6 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(20) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(See ) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(28 U.S.C. �) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1 Tw
(1491\(a\)\(1\). ) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(21) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
1 Tw
(See ) Tj
(Guong) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 860 F.2d at 1067 \(Nichols, J., concurring\). ) Tj
0 -14.2 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.45 Tw
(22) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(See Tucson Airport Auth. v. Gen. Dynamics Corp.) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 136 F.3d 641, 646) Tj
-10 -11.4 Td
1 Tw
(\(9th Cir. 1998\); ) Tj
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(see also) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( 28 U.S.C. ��) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1 Tw
(1346\(a\)\(2\), 1491\(a\)\(1\). ) Tj
10 -14.2 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.61 Tw
(23) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Tucson Airport) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 136 F.3d at 647 \() Tj
(�Because the United States' obliga-) Tj
-10 -11.4 Td
1.82 Tw
(tion is in the first instance dependent on the contract, these claims are) Tj
0 -11.4 Td
1 Tw
(contractually-based.) Tj
(�\). ) Tj
10 -14.2 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
2.06 Tw
(24) Tj
0 Ts
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Transohio Sav. Bank v. Director, Office of Thrift Supervision) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 967) Tj
-10 -11.4 Td
3.05 Tw
(F.2d 598 \(D.C. Cir. 1992\); ) Tj
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(see ) Tj
(Tucson Airport) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, 136 F.3d at 647-48) Tj
0 -11.4 Td
.36 Tw
(\(�Notwithstanding the similarities between this case and ) Tj
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Transohio) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(, to the) Tj
0 -11.4 Td
.5 Tw
(extent that the teachings of ) Tj
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Transohio) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
( relating to constitutional claims are) Tj
0 -11.4 Td
2.05 Tw
(inconsistent with the ruling case law of this court, we will not follow) Tj
0 -11.4 Td
1 Tw
(them.�\). ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -329.45 m 300 -329.45 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
439.5 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(179) Tj
-163.9697 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
36 0 obj
4671
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 35 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 10 10            
38 0 obj
<<
/Length 39 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.27 Tw
0 Tc
(should have been dismissed at the outset because it was based) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(on a covert engagement. ) Tj
0 -26.2 Td
(III.) Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Conclusion) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( ) Tj
12 -26.2 Td
0 Tw
(I sincerely hope that Totten's decedent, William Lloyd, was) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
1.22 Tw
(the only spy the United States has ever failed to pay what it) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.73 Tw
(promised \(assuming Lloyd was telling the truth\), and that the) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.14 Tw
(failure occurred only because Lincoln was assassinated before) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.52 Tw
(he could see to payment. I hope that the Does' account is fic-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.57 Tw
(tional \(though I do not intimate that it is, having no knowl-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.97 Tw
(edge\). Little could be worse for our ability to engage spies) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.58 Tw
(than insecurity about whether they will get what was prom-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.05 Tw
(ised to them. If what the Does allege is true, a serious injus-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
3.39 Tw
(tice has been done to them, and the injustice to them is) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.58 Tw
(seriously harmful to the long-term security interests of the) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(United States. ) Tj
12 -26.2 Td
.37 Tw
(Nevertheless, the judicial branch cannot right such a wrong) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
1.75 Tw
(without disclosure of the engagement's existence, which, as) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.2 Td
.57 Tw
(Totten) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( said, must remain forever secret. It will not do to have) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.83 Tw
(word circulating in whatever former Iron Curtain country the) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.25 Tw
(Does come from that the collapse of its totalitarian regime) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.93 Tw
(was brought about partly by CIA spies and not wholly by its) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.25 Tw
(own people's thirst for freedom. Joshua needed spies, Lincoln) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.47 Tw
(needed spies, we needed spies to deal with the Soviet empire,) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.58 Tw
(and spies will be needed as long as there are men on earth.) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.78 Tw
(Judicial determination of what must remain secret, even after) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.84 Tw
(in camera inspection of documents, is no substitute for dis-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.97 Tw
(missal at the outset, because the CIA cannot come into court) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.93 Tw
(and assert the existence of a secret without revealing that) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.86 Tw
(there is a secret. The use of spies is far more humane than) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.66 Tw
(some of the alternatives for dealing with serious international) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(conflicts. And their use must remain secret. ) Tj
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(180) Tj
119.5303 0 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(OE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. T) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(ENET) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
39 0 obj
3068
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 38 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 11 11            
41 0 obj
<<
/Length 42 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -8.4 Td
1.2 Tw
0 Tc
() Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
42 0 obj
120
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 41 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 12 12            
44 0 obj
<<
/Length 45 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 8 Tf 100 Tz
123.932 -444 Td
.8 Tw
0 Tc
(PRINTED FOR) Tj
-51.62 -9 Td
(ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE�U.S. COURTS) Tj
23.996 -9 Td
(BY WEST�SAN FRANCISCO) Tj
22.692 -6 Td
() Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.8 Tw
62 0 Td
-179.54 -12 Td
(The summary, which does not constitute a part of the opinion of the court, is copyrighted) Tj
82.436 -9 Td
(� 2004 by West, a Thomson Company.) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -419.75 m 300 -419.75 l s
.5 w 121 -467.75 m 181 -467.75 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
554
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 44 0 R
>>
endobj
1 0 obj
[ /PDF /Text ]
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
 31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
 254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
 131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
 228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
 209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
 214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
 221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
 25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
 252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
 144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
 141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
 ]
>>
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Bold
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [ -168 -218 1000 935 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 139.00
/StemH 69.50
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 676
/XHeight 461
/Ascent 676
/Descent -205
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F1
/BaseFont /Times-Bold
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 570 570 570 570 570 300 300
250 333 555 500 500 1000 833 333 333 333 500 570 250 333 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 333 333 570 570 570 500
930 722 667 722 722 667 611 778 778 389 500 778 667 944 722 778
611 778 722 556 667 722 722 1000 722 722 667 333 278 333 581 500
333 500 556 444 556 444 333 500 556 278 333 556 278 833 556 500
556 556 444 389 333 556 500 722 500 500 444 394 220 394 520 400
722 556 444 500 500 500 500 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 722 722
667 611 556 500 500 500 556 556 500 778 722 722 722 722 722 667
500 333 500 500 167 500 500 500 500 278 500 500 333 333 556 556
667 500 500 500 250 667 540 350 333 500 500 500 1000 1000 722 500
500 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 556 333 333 300 333 333 333
1000 722 556 250 250 250 556 389 722 500 556 667 444 747 747 1000
389 1000 389 300 389 389 778 778 667 778 1000 330 778 778 722 722
722 722 722 500 750 278 750 750 278 500 722 556 278 500 500 220 ]
/Encoding 46 0 R
/FontDescriptor 47 0 R
>>
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
 31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
 254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
 131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
 228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
 209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
 214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
 221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
 25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
 252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
 144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
 141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
 ]
>>
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Roman
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [ -168 -218 1000 898 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 84.00
/StemH 42.00
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 662
/XHeight 450
/Ascent 683
/Descent -217
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F2
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 564 564 564 564 564 300 300
250 333 408 500 500 833 778 333 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444
921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722
556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500
333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500
500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 400
667 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 722 722
611 556 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 722 722 722 722 722 722 611
444 333 500 500 167 500 500 500 500 180 444 500 333 333 556 556
611 500 500 500 250 611 453 350 333 444 444 500 1000 1000 722 444
500 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 500 333 333 300 333 333 333
1000 722 500 250 250 250 556 389 722 500 500 611 444 760 760 980
333 889 333 276 333 333 722 722 611 722 889 310 722 722 722 722
722 667 722 444 750 278 750 750 278 500 722 500 278 500 500 200 ]
/Encoding 48 0 R
/FontDescriptor 49 0 R
>>
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 240 /apple ]
>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Symbol
/Flags 4
/FontBBox [ -180 -293 1090 1010 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 85.00
/StemH 42.50
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 0
/XHeight 0
/Ascent 0
/Descent 0
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F3
/BaseFont /Symbol
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 333 713 500 549 833 778 439 333 333 500 549 250 549 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 549 549 549 444
549 722 667 722 612 611 763 603 722 333 631 722 686 889 722 722
768 741 556 592 611 690 439 768 645 795 611 333 863 333 658 500
500 631 549 549 494 439 521 411 603 329 603 549 549 576 521 549
549 521 549 603 439 576 713 686 493 686 494 480 200 480 549 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 620 247 549 167 713 500 753 753 753 753 1042 987 603 987 603
400 549 411 549 549 713 494 460 549 549 549 549 1000 603 1000 658
823 686 795 987 768 768 823 768 768 713 713 713 713 713 713 713
768 713 790 250 250 250 549 250 713 603 603 1042 987 603 987 603
494 329 790 790 786 713 384 384 384 384 384 384 494 494 494 494
790 329 274 686 686 686 384 384 384 384 384 384 494 494 494 250 ]
/Encoding 50 0 R
/FontDescriptor 51 0 R
>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
 31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
 254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
 131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
 228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
 209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
 214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
 221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
 25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
 252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
 144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
 141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
 ]
>>
endobj
53 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Italic
/Flags 98
/FontBBox [ -169 -217 1010 883 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 76.00
/StemH 38.00
/ItalicAngle -15.50
/CapHeight 653
/XHeight 441
/Ascent 683
/Descent -205
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F4
/BaseFont /Times-Italic
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 675 675 675 675 675 300 300
250 333 420 500 500 833 778 333 333 333 500 675 250 333 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 333 333 675 675 675 500
920 611 611 667 722 611 611 722 722 333 444 667 556 833 667 722
611 722 611 500 556 722 611 833 611 556 556 389 278 389 422 500
333 500 500 444 500 444 278 500 500 278 278 444 278 722 500 500
500 500 389 389 278 500 444 667 444 444 389 400 275 400 541 400
667 500 444 500 500 500 500 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 611 611
611 611 500 500 500 500 500 500 444 722 722 611 611 611 611 611
500 389 500 500 167 500 500 500 500 214 556 500 333 333 500 500
611 500 500 500 250 611 523 350 333 556 556 500 889 1000 722 500
500 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 500 333 333 300 333 333 333
889 667 500 250 250 250 500 389 556 444 500 556 389 760 760 980
333 889 333 276 333 333 722 722 556 722 944 310 722 722 722 722
722 667 556 500 750 278 750 750 278 500 667 500 278 500 500 275 ]
/Encoding 52 0 R
/FontDescriptor 53 0 R
>>
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
 31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
 254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
 131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
 228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
 209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
 214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
 221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
 25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
 252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
 144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
 141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
 ]
>>
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Helvetica-Bold
/Flags 32
/FontBBox [ -170 -228 1003 962 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 140.00
/StemH 70.00
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 718
/XHeight 532
/Ascent 718
/Descent -207
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F5
/BaseFont /Helvetica-Bold
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278
278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 584 584 584 584 584 333 333
278 333 474 556 556 889 722 278 333 333 389 584 278 333 278 278
556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 333 333 584 584 584 611
975 722 722 722 722 667 611 778 722 278 556 722 611 833 722 778
667 778 722 667 611 722 667 944 667 667 611 333 278 333 584 556
278 556 611 556 611 556 333 611 611 278 278 556 278 889 611 611
611 611 389 556 333 611 556 778 556 556 500 389 280 389 584 400
722 611 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 278 722 722
667 667 611 611 611 611 611 611 556 778 722 722 722 722 722 667
556 333 556 556 167 556 556 556 556 238 500 556 333 333 611 611
667 556 556 556 278 667 556 350 278 500 500 556 1000 1000 722 611
611 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 611 333 333 333 333 333 333
1000 722 611 278 278 278 667 556 667 556 611 611 500 737 737 1000
278 1000 278 370 278 278 778 778 611 778 1000 365 778 778 722 722
722 889 667 556 834 278 834 834 278 611 944 611 278 611 611 280 ]
/Encoding 54 0 R
/FontDescriptor 55 0 R
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Kids [3 0 R 11 0 R 14 0 R 18 0 R 21 0 R 24 0 R]
/Count 6
/Type /Pages
/Parent 56 0 R
>>
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/Kids [27 0 R 31 0 R 34 0 R 37 0 R 40 0 R 43 0 R]
/Count 6
/Type /Pages
/Parent 56 0 R
>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/Kids [10 0 R 30 0 R]
/Count 12
/Type /Pages
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/Type /Catalog
/Pages 56 0 R
>>
endobj
57 0 obj
<<
/CreationDate (Monday January 5, 2004 13:47:29)            
/Creator (VERSACOMP R05.2)   
/Producer (ECMP5)
>>
endobj
xref
0 58
0000000000 65535 f
0000043243 00000 n
0000055767 00000 n
0000003877 00000 n
0000000044 00000 n
0000003854 00000 n
0000044708 00000 n
0000047360 00000 n
0000048914 00000 n
0000051561 00000 n
0000055435 00000 n
0000006996 00000 n
0000004091 00000 n
0000006972 00000 n
0000011848 00000 n
0000007201 00000 n
0000011824 00000 n
0000054212 00000 n
0000015673 00000 n
0000012065 00000 n
0000015649 00000 n
0000019468 00000 n
0000015890 00000 n
0000019444 00000 n
0000023905 00000 n
0000019685 00000 n
0000023881 00000 n
0000028182 00000 n
0000024122 00000 n
0000028158 00000 n
0000055551 00000 n
0000033484 00000 n
0000028399 00000 n
0000033460 00000 n
0000038457 00000 n
0000033701 00000 n
0000038433 00000 n
0000041829 00000 n
0000038676 00000 n
0000041805 00000 n
0000042240 00000 n
0000042036 00000 n
0000042217 00000 n
0000043074 00000 n
0000042436 00000 n
0000043051 00000 n
0000043276 00000 n
0000044428 00000 n
0000045928 00000 n
0000047080 00000 n
0000048576 00000 n
0000048648 00000 n
0000050126 00000 n
0000051278 00000 n
0000052776 00000 n
0000053928 00000 n
0000055668 00000 n
0000055823 00000 n
trailer
<<
/Size 58
/Root 2 0 R
/Info 57 0 R
>>
startxref
55960
%%EOF